One of the most intriguing and perplexing scenes of “The Lodger” was the scene
in which the fiancé (Joe) jokingly handcuffs Daisy, upsetting both her and the
lodger (who is watching from the staircase). Why would a man who supposedly
loves and cares for Daisy put her in handcuffs and refuse to take them off when
he can see that she is obviously distressed by his actions? I believe that this
is a very important scene because it symbolizes the restricted, imprisoned life
that Daisy would lead if she were to marry the “wrong man”. In addition, the
scene casts even more suspicion on the lodger by portraying him as extremely
menacing and threatening.
The cinematography and the acting of this scene
support the idea that Joe is the wrong man for Daisy, and Joe’s unusual actions
make the audience silently root for the couple’s break-up. The camera takes a
close-up shot of Daisy’s handcuffed wrists (time stamp: 23:09), creating a
rather menacing and foreboding shot due to the pure-black background that
accentuates Daisy’s imprisoned wrists. In this shot, Joe’s hand is also tightly
clamped around Daisy’s arm, adding to Daisy’s symbolic captivity. Soon after,
the camera takes an “over the shoulder” shot of Daisy pleading with Joe to
release her (time stamp: 23:15). The slightly high angle of the camera and
Daisy’s pleading expression creates an image that is remarkably similar to the
Avenger’s screaming victim in the beginning of the film. By creating this
connection, Daisy is likened to the helpless murder victim, therefore
exaggerating her imprisoned state with Joe.
This scene also casts even more
suspicion on the lodger because he becomes very upset by Joe's actions, and the
lodger seems to barely be containing his rage. The medium close-up shot of
Jonathan’s face is extremely threatening, mainly because of the low-angle of the
camera which makes the lodger appear to be even larger than he actually is (time
stamp: 23:23). The lodger then does some deep breathing, as though he is barely
containing his anger. In addition, the shadows that fall over only one side of
his face and his bulging eyes add to his threatening appearance. The
cinematography of this scene definitely seems to incriminate the lodger and to
suggest that he is capable of great anger and violence, just like the Avenger.
You have a very interesting point of view on the relationship between Daisy and Joe. Before reading your blog entry, I believed that Joe was the one pursuing an uninterested Daisy. This was determined from the scene where Joe cuts a heart shaped piece of dough (time stamp 13:24) and passes it to Daisy. In return Daisy carelessly tosses it back to him (time stamp 14:01)which causes Joe to rip the heart up and look defeated. In addition the scene with the handcuffs was Joe's last attempt to catch her for himself.
ReplyDeleteIf the lodger was really the avenger would he be upset from joe's action?
I agree, Joe was pursuing Daisy. Although, it is still logical for Joe to want to hand cuff Daisy. Joe is a man with a lot of power in this film and him handcuffing Daisy is symbolic of him utilizing this power to "own" Daisy (handcuffs as the analogy but falsely incriminating the lodger in reality).
ReplyDelete